Review: She Walks In Beauty by Siri Mitchell

1:17 AM

Paperback: 400 pages
Publisher: Bethany House; Original edition (April 1, 2010)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0764204335
ISBN-13: 978-0764204333

Description (Publisher Website)

During New York City's Gilded Age...
The game is played amid banquets and balls.
The prize is a lifetime of wealth and privilege.
The rules will test friendships and
the desires of a young woman's heart.
Clara Carter is the social season's brightest star...
but at what cost?

For a young society woman seeking a favorable marriage, so much depends on her social season debut. Clara Carter has been given one goal: secure the affections of the city's most eligible bachelor. Debuting means plenty of work--there are corsets to be fitted, dances to master, manners to perfect. Her training soon pays off, however, as celebrity's spotlight turns Clara into a society-page darling.
Yet Clara soon wonders if this is the life she really wants. Especially when she learns her best friend has also set her sights on Franklin De Vries. When a man appears who seems to love her simply for who she is and gossip backlash turns ugly, Clara realizes it's not just her marriage at stake--the future of her family depends on how she plays the game.

About The Author (Publisher Website)
Photo courtesy of Ginger Murray Photography
Siri Mitchell is the author of nearly a dozen novels, among them the critically acclaimed Christy Award finalists Chateau of Echoes and The Cubicle Next Door. A graduate of the University of Washington with a degree in business, she has worked in many different levels of government. As military spouse, she has lived in places as varied as Tokyo and Paris. Siri currently lives in the DC-metro area. Visit

Q A With Siri Mitchell (Publisher Website)
1. This book takes place over 100 years ago in late-Victorian America. What is the
relevance for today’s reader? 

The more I learned about late-Victorian culture, the more their problems seemed to
mirror ours: a burgeoning celebrity culture, use of distortion in advertising, commitment to a single standard of beauty. Women still go to dangerous lengths to“fix” the way they look. And media and advertising still perpetuate such unreasonable standards of beauty that some women are driven to anorexia-inducing behaviors. And, like the Victorians, we also still grapple with our attitudes toward the poor.

2. What surprised you most about the time period?

The contradictions! I had to try and understand a society that sent such contradictory
messages to its young women. “No, let’s not talk about sex but we’ll make sure we
emphasize your curves to every advantage. We’ll equip you with every artifice known to
catch a man, but let’s not discuss what happens in the bedroom or the nursery. We’ll all
go to church on Sunday, but please don’t tax your mind in thinking about the sermons.
Your role in life, the only way to achieve true happiness, is to be a wife and mother, and
no, it doesn’t really matter whether you like the groom.” That was a difficult mindset to

3. Your heroine is put through a training regimen to prepare for her debut into
society. Did that really happen?

Yes, it really did, though the education generally spanned a period of years rather than
weeks. It was very important for a girl to understand the role she was expected to play
in society. Social education was both formal and informal, including etiquette as well as
religion, voice training, playing an instrument, dancing, handiwork, and household

4. In the same vein, your heroine is quite overwhelmed by the abundant variety of
silverware and serving ware that she’s expected to memorize. You can’t tell us there were really lemon forks and marrow shovels. Surely you took some artistic license in inventing them.

There were, and I didn’t! The Victorians also had vase-like celery servers and comb-like
cake breakers. Appearances were very important to Victorians in general and to the
upper levels of society in particular. This was the period of time in which old money
was being challenged by new money. As high society ways were observed and then
copied by the lower classes, new rules had to be established to preserve the old
boundaries. The Victorians did everything they could think of to differentiate between
those who had class and those who did not. They were also reluctant to be placed in the
indelicate situation of having to actually touch their food. Thus, dining was meant to
set a trap into which the unsuspecting and uneducated could easily fall. So much emphasis was placed on manners and etiquette that the result was a truly astonishing array of arcane implements like lemon forks and cake breakers.

5. What advice could a Victorian debutante offer to contemporary society?

At its foundation, etiquette and good manners are all about making people feel welcome and placing them at ease. I’m not sure we do such a good job of this today. In some corners of our culture rudeness is applauded and biting, sarcastic comments seem to have replaced more thoughtful and witty humor. Victorian women could teach us quite a bit about focusing our attention on others’ needs. Perhaps they did that to the extent that they gave up more of
themselves than they ought to have, but I think we could all stand to lean a little bit more in that direction.

6. Your heroine’s father, a doctor, appears to be a bit of a quack. Toward the end of the book, you include a recipe for his tonic. Could you enlighten us as to Victorian medicine?

Frankly, I don’t think it ought to be called medicine! It had more in common with medieval rather than modern practices. The Victorians made remarkable advancements in technology and education, but their medical establishment still based much of its “knowledge” on superstition and folk remedies. Tonics like Dr. Carter’s were very popular and common ingredients included massive amounts of alcohol, cocaine, ether, chloroform, opium,
belladonna, and digitalis.

7. What ideas are you exploring in this book? What is the take-away message you want readers to receive after reading your book?

That society will tell you who you are and how to be until you decide for yourself who you are and how you want to be.

8. Any last word to your readers?

God loves you just the way you are. So many problems, so much heartache comes when we fail to understand that, when we try to evade it or convince God that he really shouldn’t. The best thing you can do is just confront that idea and deal with it. God loves you. Let that knowledge change your life!

My Thoughts
As always, Siri Mitchell has written a gorgeous book!  I couldn't put it down, as is usually the case when I'm reading one of her books.  The story is rich and well told, the characters will instantly win you over, and her attention to historic detail is excellent. If you're a fan of historical fiction, then Siri Mitchell is an author you don't want to miss. 

You Might Also Like


Powered by Blogger.
Every year we lose more people to AIDS. It hasn't disappeared and it's not going away anytime soon. I urge you to seek out and support your local AIDS Organizations. Encourage everyone you know to practice safe sex and to get tested once a year. Even if you don't think you are at risk, get tested. I didn't think I was at risk either, and I almost died before I was diagnosed.


Grab My Badge!

Grab My Badge!

Blog Archive

Would You Like To Be Added To My Blogroll? Email Me!


Stop AIDS in the US

Ratings by outbrain

Blog Roll

Smart Solutions for Everyday Moms

As Featured On EzineArticles
Blogcritics: news and reviews
Custom Search

I'm #2395

Creative Commons License Marta's Meanderings by Marta Hoelscher is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.

Subscribe to my blog!

Subscribe to Marta's Meanderings

Twitter Button from TweetIt from HubSpot


I'd be happy to review your book. I post at many locations in addition to here on my blog. Please CONTACT me with any questions or concerns. I'll look forward to hearing from you!

web statistic

Popular Posts

Like us on Facebook

Alltop. How the hell did that happen?

Flickr Images